What Happens to Your Business If You Die Without a Buy-Sell Agreement?

Read time: minutes
Blog Graphics (43)
Table of Contents
    Add a header to begin generating the table of contents

    According to a 2024 Gallup survey, 12% of small business owners who primarily work for their business have no plan at all for what happens to it. That number does not account for the owners who have a will or a general estate plan but have never addressed what happens specifically to their ownership interest in the business. For co-owned businesses, that gap is where things fall apart. Without a buy-sell agreement, the death of one owner does not just create a personal loss. It creates a legal and financial crisis that can threaten everything the remaining owners and the deceased owner’s family were counting on.

    What Is a Buy-Sell Agreement?

    A buy-sell agreement is a legally binding contract between business co-owners that governs what happens to an owner’s share of the business when a triggering event occurs. Triggering events typically include death, disability, divorce, retirement, or a voluntary exit. The agreement establishes who can buy the departing owner’s interest, at what price, and under what terms, and it eliminates the uncertainty that would otherwise fall on the people least equipped to handle it.

    Without one, none of those questions have a predetermined answer at the exact moment when clarity matters most.

    Your Heirs Become Co-Owners

    When a business owner dies without a buy-sell agreement, their ownership interest typically passes through their estate to their heirs. Your spouse, adult children, or other beneficiaries now hold a stake in a business they may know nothing about and may have no interest in running.

    A buy-sell agreement is what prevents ownership from drifting into the wrong hands. Without one, surviving owners have no clear mechanism to buy the interest. Your co-owners are now in business with people they did not choose, who have no operational role, no relevant expertise, and entirely different financial priorities. That combination creates conflict even when everyone involved has good intentions.

    A well-drafted buy-sell agreement addresses what happens to the ownership interest of a deceased owner, the terms of a buyout, the timeframe for completing it, how the purchase price will be determined, and whether the buyout is paid in cash or over time. These are all terms that are far better established by the owners in advance than fought over after one owner dies.

    Valuation and Funding: Where It Gets Expensive

    Without a pre-agreed valuation method, your heirs and your surviving co-owners are left to negotiate the value of the business from opposing positions. Your heirs want to maximize the estate. Your co-owners want to minimize what they pay. Both sides bring in appraisers. Attorneys get involved. The process is expensive, slow, and damaging to the business and everyone connected to it.

    Even if both sides agree on value, the buyout may be impossible to fund. Even when there is a buy-sell agreement, it often is not funded. The agreement might require the company to buy out the deceased owner’s interest, but the business may not have the cash. Without life insurance or another funding mechanism built into the agreement from the start, the surviving owners may be forced to take on debt, sell business assets, or pursue an outright sale of the company at a price that reflects urgency rather than fair market value.

    The Estate Tax Problem Just Got More Complicated

    The estate tax implications of dying without a buy-sell agreement became more complex after a 2024 Supreme Court decision. In Connelly v. United States, the Court unanimously held that life insurance proceeds received by a company to fund a stock redemption are included in the company’s fair market value for estate tax purposes, and that the redemption obligation does not offset that value. For closely held business owners with redemption agreements, this can mean a larger taxable estate than anticipated. The 40% federal estate tax rate still applies to amounts above the exemption threshold, and business owners who have not reviewed their buy-sell structure since Connelly should.

    A Note on Entity Type

    The specific consequences of dying without a buy-sell agreement vary depending on how the business is structured. In a partnership, state default rules may govern ownership transfers in the absence of a written agreement, and those rules rarely align with what the owners would have chosen. In an S corporation, a transfer of ownership to an ineligible shareholder, such as certain trusts or nonresident aliens, can inadvertently terminate the S election, creating immediate and significant tax consequences. In an LLC, the operating agreement controls, and if it is silent on the issue, state law fills the gap in ways that may surprise everyone involved.

    Many owners have wills or trusts but never updated the operating agreement, shareholder agreement, or partnership documents. The result is that the estate plan says one thing, but the business documents say another. A buy-sell agreement resolves that conflict before it becomes litigation.

    What a Buy-Sell Agreement Actually Does

    A well-drafted buy-sell agreement answers the questions that otherwise get left to chance. It establishes who has the right or obligation to purchase the departing owner’s interest, how the business will be valued, how the purchase will be funded, a timeline for completing the transaction, and restrictions on ownership transfers to outside parties.

    There are several common structures, including cross-purchase agreements, entity-purchase or redemption agreements, and hybrid arrangements. Each has different tax implications, and the right choice depends on the number of owners, the business structure, and individual circumstances. Following the Connelly decision, the funding structure and how life insurance is owned deserve particularly careful attention.

    Conclusion

    A buy-sell agreement is not a complicated concept. It is a commitment between co-owners to treat each other fairly and protect the business if the unexpected happens. What makes it complicated is everything that happens without one: heirs who become unwilling co-owners, valuation disputes that drain resources, forced sales at the wrong time, and estate tax exposure that has grown more complex in the wake of recent court decisions. The cost of putting an agreement in place is a fraction of what it costs to sort out the aftermath without one. Getting it done, and keeping it current, is one of the most straightforward ways to protect what you have built.

    Disclaimer

    This blog post is intended for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, or financial advice. Buy-sell agreements involve complex legal and tax considerations that vary based on business structure, state law, and individual circumstances. The information regarding Connelly v. United States is provided for educational purposes and should not be relied upon as legal guidance. Please consult a qualified attorney, CPA, or financial advisor before making any decisions related to business succession planning.

    Works Cited

    Gallup. (2025, March 25). Most small-business owners lack a succession plan. https://news.gallup.com/poll/657362/small-business-owners-lack-succession-plan.aspx

    Harris Beach Murtha. (2024, August 19). It’s time to revisit buy-sell agreements after the Supreme Court’s Connelly decision. https://www.harrisbeachmurtha.com/insights/its-time-to-revisit-buy-sell-agreements-after-the-supreme-courts-connelly-decision/

    Moore Colson. (2024, October 1). Connelly v. United States: What the ruling means for estate taxes. https://moorecolson.com/news-insights/connelly-v-united-states-what-the-ruling-means-estate-taxes/

    Business Law Group. (2026, February 23). What happens to a business when an owner dies? https://www.lawgroup.biz/what-happens-to-a-business-when-an-owner-dies-and-why-most-plans-fail

    Lins Law Group. (2023). Will your business die when you die? https://www.linslawgroup.com/blog/2020/05/will-your-business-die-when-you-die/

    Related Articles

    Blog Graphics (53)

    The Hidden Tax Problem with Remote Employees

    Here's a scenario we see all the time. A business owner finds the perfect candidate,...
    Blog Graphics (32)

    What Every Employer Needs to Know Before Hiring Summer Interns

    Hiring a summer intern can be one of the best moves a small business makes:...
    Be Wary of Social Media ‘Fin-Fluencers’

    Be Wary of Social Media ‘Fin-Fluencers’

    Increasingly, online social media personalities want to tell you what to do with your wealth....