The Hidden Tax Problem with Remote Employees
Here’s a scenario we see all the time. A business owner finds the perfect candidate, someone sharp, experienced, exactly what the role needs, and the only catch is they live two states away. Doesn’t matter, right? It’s a remote job. The offer goes out, the laptop ships, and everyone moves on. And honestly, that instinct is a good one, remote hiring can be a great move for a small business.
But nothing about that hire is quite as simple as it felt. The moment that employee logs on from their home office, your business has likely picked up new tax obligations in a state you’ve never set foot in. We watch this play out constantly: everything runs smoothly for a year or two, and then a notice shows up from a state department of revenue asking why the business hasn’t registered, withheld income tax, or paid unemployment insurance there. By then, penalties and back taxes are already piling up. None of it had to happen, and none of it means you should think twice about hiring remote. It just means the tax side needs the same amount of thought as the hiring decision itself.
One Remote Hire, New Filing Requirements
The legal word for what just happened is nexus, and it’s a simpler idea than it sounds: it’s the connection between your business and a state that gives that state the right to tax you. Here’s the part that surprises people. In most states, it takes exactly one employee working from a home office to create that connection. Not a warehouse. Not a sales office. One person, one laptop, one kitchen table.
And once that connection exists, the state doesn’t ask nicely. It can expect your business to register as an employer, withhold state income tax, register for unemployment insurance, and in some cases file corporate income or franchise tax returns, whether or not you ever intended to “do business” there. If you’re running a business here in Texas, this one stings a little extra. We don’t have a state income tax, so withholding has never been on your radar. But hire someone in a state that does have one, and suddenly you’re playing by their rules, on their calendar, for an employee who’s never set foot in your office.
The “Convenience of the Employer” Trap
Just when you think you’ve got a handle on it, a handful of states throw in a curveball called the convenience of the employer rule. The short version: if your employee is working remotely for their own comfort rather than because the job truly requires it, the state can tax those wages as if the work happened at your office, not their house. New York enforces this the hardest, and several other states run their own versions of it. The result can be an employer or an employee owing tax to two states on the exact same paycheck. These rules keep shifting and getting challenged in court, so this isn’t something to set and forget. It’s worth a direct conversation the moment it might apply to you.
Don’t Forget Unemployment Insurance and Local Taxes
Income tax withholding gets all the attention, but don’t sleep on unemployment insurance. It’s every bit as real an obligation, and it follows the employee’s state, not yours. Skipping it doesn’t make it disappear, it just means it resurfaces later as a compliance problem instead of a routine filing. Then there’s the layer most owners never see coming: local taxes. Pennsylvania alone has thousands of local tax collection districts, and whether your employee owes one can hinge on something as small as working from home instead of commuting into the city. It’s exactly the kind of detail that slips through the cracks when a hire happens fast.
What We Recommend Before You Make the Next Remote Hire
None of this means you should shy away from hiring remote. It means the tax questions belong in the conversation before the offer goes out, not after the first paycheck clears. Before your next remote hire, walk through this list:
- Confirm the employee’s actual work state, including any plans to relocate or split time between states
- Check whether that state requires employer registration for income tax withholding and unemployment insurance
- Determine whether a convenience of the employer rule applies to the arrangement, and document the business reason for remote work if it does
- Identify any local or municipal tax obligations tied to the employee’s specific city or county
- Build the registration and filing calendar into your process before the first payroll runs, not after a notice arrives
Don’t Let This Be a Reason to Skip Remote Hiring
None of this changes the fact that remote hiring can be a great move for a small business. The tax and compliance side isn’t a reason to avoid it, it’s just the part that has to be handled with the same care as the hiring decision itself. Get the registration, withholding, and filing pieces right from the start, and there’s no reason a great remote hire should ever turn into a costly surprise a year or two down the road. If you’re weighing a remote hire, expanding into a new state, or you’ve already got employees scattered across state lines and you’re not entirely sure where you stand, let’s talk it through before it becomes a problem instead of after.
Disclaimer
This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute tax, legal, or accounting advice. State tax rules, including nexus standards and convenience of the employer rules, vary by state and change frequently, including through ongoing litigation. Please consult with a qualified tax professional regarding your specific situation before making decisions based on this information.
Works Cited
SmartAsset, “What Is the Convenience of the Employer Rule?”
Mosey, “The Convenience of the Employer Rule and COE States”
ADP SPARK Blog, “When Remote Workers Cross State Lines: Tax, Compliance and Employer Risks”
Alloy Silverstein, “Working Remotely in a Different State from Your Employer?”
Warp, “Remote Employees and State Tax Nexus: 2026 Guide”
Anomaly CPA, “Do Remote Employees Create State Tax Nexus?”RSM US, “Remote Workforces Are Complicating State Tax Nexus and Withholding”
Related Articles