What Every Employer Needs to Know Before Hiring Summer Interns
Hiring a summer intern can be one of the best moves a small business makes: extra capacity during a busy season, a chance to mentor the next generation, and a low-risk way to evaluate future hires. But many small business owners don’t realize that bringing on an intern comes with the same legal and payroll obligations as hiring any other employee. Here are five things you need to have sorted before your intern’s first day.
1. You almost certainly have to pay them
A lot of small businesses assume that offering an “unpaid internship” is straightforward, especially if the intern is a student, earns college credit, or volunteers for the role. But federal law under the Fair Labor Standards Act sets a high bar for unpaid internships. The key question is: who benefits more from the work? If your intern is answering emails, helping with bookkeeping, assisting customers, or doing anything that keeps your business running, you are the primary beneficiary and they must be paid at least minimum wage.
College credit does not satisfy this requirement, and neither does the intern’s willingness to work for free. When in doubt, pay your intern. The legal exposure from getting this wrong far outweighs the cost of a few weeks of wages.
2. Don’t pay them as a contractor
For many small business owners, the simplest-seeming solution is to pay the intern a lump sum and send a 1099 at year-end. It avoids payroll setup, feels informal, and seems to match the temporary nature of the role. Unfortunately, it’s also wrong and potentially expensive to fix later.
The IRS looks at who controls how, when, and where work gets done. If your intern works your hours, uses your equipment, and follows your direction, they are an employee, not an independent contractor. Misclassifying them means you could owe back payroll taxes, penalties, and interest if you’re ever audited. The right move is to add them to payroll as a W-2 employee from day one.
3. Withholding: what you’re actually required to do
Once your intern is on payroll as a W-2 employee, you’re responsible for withholding and remitting several types of taxes on their behalf. The first step is collecting a completed W-4 on day one. This form tells you how much federal income tax to withhold based on the intern’s filing status and any adjustments they choose to make.
Beyond income tax, you’re also responsible for FICA taxes: Social Security (6.2%) and Medicare (1.45%). These are split between employer and employee. You withhold the employee’s share from their paycheck and pay a matching amount yourself. State income tax withholding applies in most states as well, with rules that vary by location.
One thing to watch: some student interns will claim “exempt” from federal income tax withholding on their W-4, which is allowed only if they had zero tax liability last year and expect the same this year. It’s a legitimate election for some, but not all. A brief conversation during onboarding can prevent surprises come tax season. Regardless of withholding status, your intern will need a W-2 issued by January 31 of the following year.
4. Stipends and allowances are usually taxable
Offering a housing stipend or travel allowance to sweeten the deal for your intern? Those payments are almost always taxable compensation, not reimbursements. The IRS distinguishes between accountable reimbursements, which cover specific documented business expenses, and flat cash allowances, which don’t. A lump-sum housing payment falls into the latter category and must be treated as wages: run through payroll, taxed, and reported on the W-2.
The mistake we see most often is paying these as a separate check outside of payroll and treating it as an informal arrangement. If you’re ever audited, those payments will be treated as unreported wages, with back taxes and penalties to match. If you’re unsure how a specific payment should be classified, it’s worth a quick conversation with your accountant before you cut the check.
5. Paperwork and workers’ comp: don’t skip either
Because internships feel casual, many small businesses skip the standard onboarding steps. Don’t. You’ll need a Form I-9 completed within three days of the start date, the W-4 mentioned above, and a new-hire report filed with your state. Most states require this within 20 days of hire. Track hours carefully too: interns are non-exempt workers, which means overtime rules apply if they exceed 40 hours in a week. A simple offer letter spelling out pay rate, dates, and expectations is also worth putting in writing for both parties.
Workers’ compensation is the piece that most small business owners overlook entirely. Workers’ comp is insurance that covers employees for medical costs and lost wages if they’re injured on the job, and in nearly every state it’s legally required for all W-2 employees, including short-term and seasonal ones. That means your intern is covered from their first day of work, whether you’ve thought about it or not.
The practical issue is that some insurers require you to notify them when you add temporary workers mid-policy year, and your premium may be calculated based on total payroll, including your intern’s wages. If you haven’t updated your policy and an injury occurs, you could face a coverage gap or a dispute with your carrier. A quick call before your intern starts is all it takes to make sure you’re covered properly.
The bottom line
Hiring an intern is genuinely worthwhile, and the compliance side of it is manageable once you know what to look for. The businesses that run into trouble are almost always the ones who kept things too informal: skipping payroll setup, paying cash, or skipping paperwork because it felt like overkill for a short-term hire. A little preparation upfront goes a long way.
Disclaimer
This article is intended for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, or accounting advice. Employment laws and tax regulations vary by state and are subject to change. You should consult a qualified attorney, CPA, or HR professional regarding your specific situation before making decisions about hiring, classification, or payroll practices.
Related Articles