When Does Your Side Hustle Become a Business? The IRS 9-Factor Test Every Side Hustler Should Know

Read time: minutes
Social Media Tips & Infographics (Facebook Post) (61)
Table of Contents
    Add a header to begin generating the table of contents

    Whether you’re selling candles on Etsy, freelancing on weekends, or flipping vintage furniture, there’s a question you’ll eventually need to answer: is this a hobby or a business?

    It might feel like a philosophical distinction, but to the IRS, it’s anything but. How they classify your activity determines whether you can deduct your expenses — or whether you owe taxes on every dollar of income with nothing to offset it.

    Why the Classification Matters

    If the IRS considers your activity a hobby, the income is fully taxable but expenses are not deductible. Hobby income is reported as “other income” on Schedule 1 of Form 1040. If it’s classified as a business, income and expenses are reported on Schedule C, and losses may be able to offset other income.

    It’s worth noting that the classification isn’t purely one-sided. Business income is subject to self-employment tax when net earnings reach $400 or more, while hobby income is not.

    The IRS 9-Factor Test

    Under Internal Revenue Code Section 183, the IRS evaluates activities against nine factors. No single factor is decisive. They look at the full picture.

    1. Do you run the activity in a businesslike manner? This includes keeping complete and accurate books, maintaining a separate bank account, and operating with practices similar to other profitable businesses in the same field.

    2. Do you invest time and effort toward making it profitable? The IRS looks at whether you’re putting in substantial time — particularly if you don’t have another full-time job. Treating the activity like work rather than a casual pursuit signals profit intent.

    3. Do you depend on the income for your livelihood? If the income from the activity is a meaningful part of how you support yourself, that weighs in favor of business status. A side activity done purely for enjoyment carries less weight here.

    4. Are your losses typical of a startup or beyond your control? Losses in the early years of a new venture are common and expected. The IRS also considers whether losses were caused by circumstances outside your control, like market downturns or supply chain issues, versus a pattern of indefinite losses with no clear path to profitability.

    5. Have you changed your approach to improve profitability? A business owner adapts. The IRS looks at whether you’ve adjusted pricing, marketing, methods, or operations in response to losses, or whether you’ve continued doing the same thing regardless of results.

    6. Do you or your advisors have relevant expertise? Having knowledge, training, or experience in the field — or working with advisors who do — supports the idea that you’re operating with serious intent rather than casually.

    7. Have you profited from similar activities before? A track record matters. If you’ve successfully turned a similar activity into a profitable one in the past, that history supports a profit motive for the current activity.

    8. Does the activity make a profit in some years, and how much? The IRS considers not just whether you’ve turned a profit, but how much and how often. Small or infrequent profits relative to the size of the losses and investment involved may not be enough on their own.

    9. Could assets used in the activity appreciate in value? Even if the activity itself isn’t generating annual profit, the IRS considers whether assets involved, like real estate, equipment, or inventory, are likely to appreciate, creating the potential for profit down the line.

    The IRS may also consider the degree of personal pleasure involved in the activity. If an activity is inherently recreational, that can raise the bar for demonstrating a genuine profit motive.

    The Safe Harbor Rule

    There’s also an objective benchmark. If an activity shows a profit in at least three out of five consecutive tax years, the IRS generally presumes it’s a business. For activities involving horses, the threshold is two out of seven years.

    Not meeting this threshold doesn’t automatically mean hobby status, but it does increase the likelihood of closer review.

    The Bottom Line

    The line between hobby and business isn’t always obvious, but the IRS has a clear framework for drawing it. If you’re earning money from a side activity, it’s worth understanding where that activity falls under these factors. A qualified tax professional can help evaluate your specific situation.

    Disclaimer

    This post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute tax, legal, or financial advice. Tax laws are complex and subject to change. The information presented here is based on publicly available IRS guidance and federal tax law as of 2026. Individual circumstances vary — consult a qualified tax professional for guidance on your specific situation.

    Works Cited

    • Internal Revenue Service. “Hobby or Business: What People Need to Know if They Have a Side Hustle.” IRS Tax Tip 2024-55. irs.gov
    • Internal Revenue Code Section 183: Activities Not Engaged in for Profit. law.cornell.edu
    • Treasury Regulation 1.183-2(b): Activity Not Engaged in for Profit Defined.
    • Internal Revenue Service. Publication 535: Business Expenses.
    • One Big Beautiful Bill Act, P.L. 119-21 (2025).

    Related Articles

    Blog Graphics (2)

    Valuing Your Business: An Entrepreneurial Best Practice

    Do you know—really know—what your business is worth? There’s a good chance that the answer...
    Blog Graphics (3)

    Financial Fraud: The Schemes Putting Your Wealth at Risk

    Fraud is nothing new, but in 2025 it is evolving in ways that directly threaten...
    Blog Graphics (6)

    How Trust Taxation Really Works (And Why It Surprises People)

    Trusts are often created to provide structure, protection, or long-term planning benefits. But when tax...